A World of Vortices or Empty Space? Descartes, Newton, and the Making of Scientific Systems
Event: NEC Seminar
Location: NEC conference room & Zoom
18 November 2026, 11.00-13.00 (Bucharest time)
Monica SOLOMON, Ștefan Odobleja Fellow; Assistant Professor, Bilkent University
How can we explain or investigate one part of nature when everything around it is also acting upon it? This question connects my book project, Constituting Systems, to the seventeenth-century debate over matter, motion, and the possibility of a vacuum. Descartes described a universe entirely filled with matter, where circulating currents and vast vortices explained physical processes, including planetary motion. Newton’s unfinished manuscript De gravitatione challenges Descartes’s understanding of space, bodies, and motion while investigating how bodies and fluids can remain in equilibrium. Taking this manuscript as my starting point, I explore how Newton’s philosophy and mathematical reasoning developed together: how could a world of interacting bodies be divided into manageable objects of inquiry, and what justified the simplifications involved? The comparison reveals that the emergence of modern physics involved both new laws of nature and new ways of deciding which bodies, boundaries, and interactions an explanation must include.
*
NEC seminars as well as meetings of the research groups can be attended by the fellows and the alumni of the programs, and their guests.
They are not open to the general public, and attendance is only by invitation, or by permission as a result of a request addressed to NEC by e-mail [nec @ nec.ro].